Institutional Objectives in College Admissions and the Power of Extracurricular Involvement
Why Colleges Build a Class, Not Just Admit High Achievers
Most applicants to top universities know the stakes. They have very strong GPAs based on taking the most rigorous classes they can take and they have standardized tests scores that match. So how might an admissions officer at one of these elite schools differentiate these students from each other.
Well, for one thing, every school has its own set of Institutional initiatives which are the priorities or objectives a school is actively trying to accomplish when shaping an incoming class. They are seeking to build a class that fits what the university currently needs. Akin to casting for a movie, they have roles to fill: star athletes, musicians, researchers, and coders and a myriad of other roles they seek to cast. It is also something that a student has no control over. A student with a 3.7 GPA may become more attractive than one with a 3.95 GPA if that student fulfills one of these objectives.
They may be seeking academic program growth such as: more computer science/AI students, more engineering or business students, more foreign language majors, or possibly education, public health or even humanities. Certain schools under the universities umbrella have target numbers for each admissions cycle.
Geographic diversity and socioeconomic access is another common institutional objective. They may be attempting to increase out-of-state or international enrollment, admit more rural students, or admit fewer students from overrepresented high schools or regions of the country. In any given cycle they may be seeking more first-generation students, ones from lower-income brackets, or students from under-resourced schools. Additionally, state flagship universities, as publicly funded institutions, have a foundational mission to prioritize the enrollment of in-state residents, often guided by state-mandated quotas or targets to ensure taxpayer-funded access
Retention also plays a critical role in admissions decisions: Does this student have the preparation, resilience, and fit to thrive on our campus? Institutions are evaluating not only the likelihood that a student will enroll, but also their potential to persist and ultimately graduate.
Furthermore, in shaping an incoming class, institutions evaluate the broader campus community—not just academic credentials, but the overall composition, character, and contributions each student will bring. Admissions officers frequently ask themselves a version of, "What will this student do here?" Thus, they review activities with a keen eye. Might they find a musician for the orchestra, theater participants, reporters for the newspaper, research assistants, peer tutors, a camp counselor who will likely make a great resident advisor, leaders for student government or someone who might start a baking club?
Why Authentic Extracurricular Activities Matter in College Admissions
A discussion of institutional objectives creates a natural segway to extracurricular involvement. You hear the word ‘authenticity’ bantered about constantly in college admissions, and it couldn’t mean more than when it comes to the activities a student participates in during their high school career. Admissions wants to see self-starters - applicants who demonstrate initiative, proactivity and commitment.
The most attractive activities are the ones a student started, changed, built, or improved.
Humdrum: Member of 5 clubs; attended meetings.
Eye-Catching: Founded animal shelter support program; organized robotics outreach; created mental health campaign; started a small business; built an app people actually use; resurrected a defunct club. Colleges are looking for doers not joiners. They want students who will create opportunities on campus. Passive involvement doesn’t resonate the way action does.
Leadership is powerful in colleges admissions if:
You saw a need and addressed it
You solved problems
You initiated change
Others depended on you
You organized people
You made decisions
Impact impresses admissions. Was a program expanded? Were people helped? What change did this student’s involvement create?
Commitment and duration - choosing something meaningful, sticking with it, growing within it, making a difference.
Overall, activities become powerful when they show at least one of these:
You built something
You solved a problem
You helped people consistently
You created knowledge
You performed at a high level
You taught others
You took responsibility
Activities help you to show not tell colleges about your motivation, character, initiative, and future impact because (back to the authenticity concept) they reveal what you choose to do when you are not being required to do so.
To learn more about how Gateway Admissions can assist with optimizing your application process and success, please request a complimentary consultation to get started.